Sign up with NauticEd for FREE (no obligation) and receive 2 free boating courses, a free eLogbook and boating resume, and more! If you want to get started in boating or are experienced and want to expand your knowledge and skills, consider taking our many online sailing and powerboating courses.
Lost Treasures of the Seas
When you think of the word “treasure,” what comes to mind? Maybe it’s the face of someone dear, a priceless relic guarded in a cavern waiting for the likes of Dr. Jones or Lady Croft, or perhaps a glimmering mound of gold beneath the watchful eye of a slumbering dragon. Maybe it’s a chest of ancient doubloons tucked away in a hidden cave. All solid answers, and in a sense, all right. Well, maybe not the dragon part—but you get the idea.
While it’s impossible to determine exactly what people imagine when they think of “treasure,” one form undoubtedly stands out: shipwrecks. Whether for their frequency or sheer material worth, sunken ships—from cargo vessels to royal transports and military fleets—hold a mystique unlike any other, tracing a silhouette through history and the ocean’s depths.
Sure, battles at sea and pirates have claimed their fair share of ships over the centuries. But let’s not forget the hand of Neptune, Poseidon, or whatever sea deity you believe in, that has also played a role in sending many to their watery graves.
With that in mind, I’ve compiled a list of some of the most legendary and valuable shipwrecks still rumored to be lying beneath the waves…
HMS Sussex
On March 1, 1694, the HMS Sussex, an 80-gun third-rate ship of the line, met her tragic end off the coast of Gibraltar during a devastating storm. As a heavily armed warship of the Royal Navy, concerns had been raised about the weight distribution on her two-deck design, though the true cause of her sinking remains a mystery.
It is believed that the Sussex was carrying an extraordinary fortune—around 10 tons of gold coins, now estimated to be worth $500 million. This treasure was intended to strengthen British alliances and support military campaigns.
The storm that claimed the Sussex also wreaked havoc on the surrounding seas, destroying 13 other ships and leading to over 1,200 deaths. The sinking of the HMS Sussex remains one of the worst disasters in the history of the Royal Navy, and despite numerous efforts, her treasure-laden wreck still lies undiscovered in the deep waters off Gibraltar.
Nuestra Señora de las Mercedes
On October 5, 1804, the Spanish frigate Nuestra Señora de las Mercedes met a tragic end during the Battle of Cape Santa Maria. At the time, Spain and England were supposedly at peace. However, as history often reminds us, the rules on the open sea aren’t always so straightforward. The Spanish ship was part of a flotilla intercepted by a Royal Navy task force, which demanded they sail to a British port for inspection. Despite being heavily outgunned and outnumbered, the captain of Mercedes, confident that no conflict existed between the two nations, refused to comply.
That refusal led to a single, fateful shot from HMS Amphion, which struck the Mercedes‘ powder magazine. The resulting explosion obliterated the ship, killing nearly all of the 250 sailors on board. At the time of her sinking, Nuestra Señora de las Mercedes was carrying an immense fortune—around 14.5 tons of gold and silver coins, worth an estimated $500 million in today’s market. As was customary for Spanish ships of that era, these treasures were destined for the Spanish crown, but instead, they now rest at the bottom of the sea.
Blessing of Burntisland
On July 10, 1633, the Blessing of Burntisland, a wooden ferry tasked with navigating the perilous waters of Scotland’s Firth of Forth, sank during a violent storm. On board was a vast royal treasure, which to this day remains undiscovered. It’s said the ship was laden with 20 carts of jewels, along with 4 to 5 tons of gold and silver—valued at an estimated $738 million in today’s terms.
What makes this shipwreck even more extraordinary is the aftermath. King Charles I, unwilling to accept that natural forces had claimed the ship, blamed its sinking on witchcraft. A number of supposed witches were subsequently put on trial and executed, their fate entwined with the loss of one of the richest treasures to vanish beneath the waves. Yes, you read that right—witches were held responsible for the tragedy.
SS Central America
In September 1857, the SS Central America, a 280-foot sidewheel steamer known as the “Ship of Gold,” sank off the US East Coast after battling a fierce hurricane. On a voyage from Panama to New York City, the ship was carrying a staggering 30,000 pounds of gold, freshly mined during the California Gold Rush. After a brief stop in Havana, disaster struck when the ship was caught in a Category 2 hurricane. For days, SS Central America was pounded by relentless winds and rough seas.
Her demise was sealed when a paddle wheel’s seal broke, allowing water to flood the ship. Despite passengers and crew desperately trying to bail out the water, they couldn’t keep up with the deluge. When the rising water reached the boilers, the ship lost power to the bilge pumps and was left dead in the water. Though other vessels managed to rescue 153 people, tragically, 425 souls were lost along with the ship.
At the time, the SS Central America’s lost cargo was valued at $8 million—a fortune intended to stabilize New York’s banks during an economic downturn. Adjusted for today, that lost gold is worth approximately $765 million. The ship’s sinking played a significant role in worsening the financial panic of 1857, compounding the already troubled economic climate.
Merchant Royal
The Merchant Royal holds the title as one of the most valuable shipwrecks in history. This English merchant ship had spent two years trading with Spanish colonies in the West Indies, accumulating vast wealth. On her return journey to England, the Merchant Royal made a stop at the port of Cadiz, where it was noted that the ship was already leaking badly.
At the same time, another vessel in the port, scheduled to carry the wages of 30,000 Spanish soldiers, caught fire. Sensing an opportunity, the captain of the Merchant Royal offered to transport the soldiers’ wages to Antwerp on his way back to England—sealing the ship’s fate by overloading it with even more treasure.
On September 23, 1641, off the coast of Land’s End, rough weather proved too much for the ailing vessel. The bilge pumps failed, and the heavily laden ship sank, taking with it an incredible fortune. The Merchant Royal was carrying at least 100,000 pounds of gold, 400 bars of silver, and nearly 500,000 pieces of eight. In today’s currency, this sunken treasure is worth an estimated $1.5 billion.
Despite numerous searches, the Merchant Royal remains undiscovered, her legendary cargo still lost to the depths.
RMS Republic
The RMS Republic, a steam-powered ocean liner built in 1903, enjoyed a prestigious career until her sinking in 1909. Known as the “Millionaire’s Ship,” she frequently ferried some of the wealthiest people of the era between destinations like Liverpool, Boston, New York, and the Mediterranean. Her luxury and affluent clientele made her a standout among the ocean liners of the day.
On the early morning of January 23, 1909, while en route from New York City to the Mediterranean, RMS Republic found herself navigating thick fog off the coast of Nantucket. Following maritime protocol, she continuously signaled her position as she passed through the outbound shipping lane. However, at 5:47 a.m., the fog revealed another ocean liner, the SS Florida. Despite immediate orders for “full reverse” and “hard to port,” the SS Florida emerged from the mist and collided with Republic, striking her amidships on the port side.
The damage was severe. Water quickly flooded the engine and boiler rooms, leaving the ship powerless. While the Republic, like the Titanic, didn’t have enough lifeboats for everyone on board, her location in a high-traffic area meant that help arrived in time. Most passengers and crew were rescued by nearby ships.
But the RMS Republic wasn’t just carrying passengers. It was reported that she held $3 million in U.S. gold Double Eagles, destined as payroll for the U.S. Navy’s Great White Fleet. In today’s terms, that treasure is valued at over $1 billion.
She now rests 50 miles south of Nantucket at a depth of 270 feet, with her lost treasure still waiting to be recovered.
San José
The San José, the flagship of the Spanish Treasure Fleet, was a formidable 64-gun, three-masted galleon that met its tragic fate in 1708 during a fierce naval battle south of Colombia. Sailing from Panama to Colombia, the San José was part of a convoy that included three Spanish warships and 14 merchant vessels when they encountered a British squadron in what would become known as Wager’s Action.
In the heat of battle, disaster struck. The powder magazine of the San José detonated, causing a massive explosion that obliterated the ship and took the lives of all 589 souls aboard. The San José was heavily laden with treasures collected from South America’s colonies, intended to fund the Spanish king’s ongoing war efforts.
Though the exact amount of wealth she carried remains uncertain, it is estimated that the San José held an astounding $17 billion worth of gold, silver, and emeralds. Discovered by the Colombian Navy in November 2015, the wreck of the San José has since been shrouded in secrecy, its vast treasure still a closely guarded state secret.
Earlier this year, the UN estimated that over 3 million shipwrecks lie scattered across the ocean floor. While not all are as legendary or valuable as the ones I’ve highlighted today, they range from small dinghies to massive battleships, and everything in between—lost to the sea, yet still out there somewhere.
You might wonder why so many remain untouched. The truth is, apart from the fact that some are simply too deep or challenging for us to recover, there’s actually a surprising benefit to leaving them undisturbed. Man-made structures on the seabed often attract marine life, eventually becoming thriving ecosystems. Some shipwrecks even develop into full-fledged reefs. This phenomenon is so effective that intentional wrecks are sometimes created to revive depleted fishing waters or establish new fishing grounds.
In a strange and unintended way, the sea has a remarkable ability to adapt and make use of our mistakes, turning human misfortunes into new opportunities for life.
You can learn more with NauticEd
Sign up with NauticEd for FREE (no obligation) and receive 2 free boating courses, a free eLogbook and boating resume, and more! If you want to get started in boating or are experienced and want to expand your knowledge and skills, consider taking our many online sailing and powerboating courses.
Author
NauticEd is a fully recognized education and certification platform for sailing students combining online and on-the-water real instruction (and now VR). NauticEd offers +24 online courses, a free sailor's toolkit that includes 2 free courses, and six ranks of certification – all integrated into NauticEd’s proprietary platform. The USCG and NASBLA recognize NauticEd as having met the established American National Standards. Learn more at www.nauticed.org.
The NauticEd Vacations team are Expert Global Yacht Charter Agents – when you book a sailing vacation or bareboat charter through NauticEd, we don’t charge you a fee – we often save you money since we can compare prices from all yacht charter companies. PLUS, we can give you advice on which destination or charter company will suit your needs best. Inquire about a Sailing Vacation or Charter.
