We’ve been there!
We did a Thanksgiving trip to Puerto Rico and the SVI with a group of friends on three catamarans a few years back. We wrote up an extensive blog (see the link below) on the area. We had so much fun and the sailing area was fantastic. We felt like this area was like the BVI would have been 20 years ago. It was completely safe – people were friendly – we found remote anchorages and beaches to ourselves – we enjoyed the Dinghy Dock Restaurant and bar in Ensenada Hondo – the scuba diving was delightful – and afterward we visited the awesome and historic city of Old San Juan. Good times were had and we are definitely going back.